The Truth About Off-Market Listings: Are You Missing Out?

The Truth About Off-Market Listings: Are You Missing Out?

  • Dennis Hartley
  • 10/24/25

In the fast-paced South Bay real estate market, properties can move quickly—sometimes before they ever appear online. These are known as off-market listings (or “pocket listings”), and they’ve become a growing topic among both buyers and sellers. But what exactly are they, and are you missing out by not paying attention to them?

What Are Off-Market Listings?

 

An off-market listing is a property that’s for sale but not publicly advertised on the MLS (Multiple Listing Service) or major home search websites. Instead, it’s shared privately among real estate agents and their clients. Sellers often choose this route for privacy, to test pricing quietly, or to limit foot traffic while still exploring potential offers.

Why Buyers Care

 

For buyers, off-market listings can feel like discovering a secret opportunity. Since these homes aren’t competing for public attention, there’s often less competition—and sometimes, a chance to negotiate more favorable terms. However, finding them typically requires a strong agent network. Agents with deep South Bay connections, like those within Compass, often have early or exclusive access to properties before they hit the open market.

Why Sellers Consider It

 

For some sellers, keeping a home off the MLS offers control and discretion. They may prefer a quieter sale due to personal reasons, privacy concerns, or a desire to test buyer response before officially listing. This can work well for high-end properties, unique homes, or sellers who want to avoid the traditional marketing process.

 

However, it’s not always the right fit for everyone. Without the exposure of the full market, a seller may limit their pool of potential buyers—and possibly their final sale price.

Pros and Cons at a Glance

 

For Buyers:
✅ Access to homes not publicly listed
✅ Potentially less competition
⚠️ Harder to find without the right agent

 

For Sellers:
✅ More privacy and control
✅ Can test price quietly before going public
⚠️ Reduced visibility may mean fewer offers

The Bottom Line

 

Off-market listings can be valuable—but only if you’re working with an agent who’s deeply connected in the South Bay real estate community. With the right guidance, buyers can uncover hidden gems, and sellers can explore private sale options that align with their goals.

 

Wondering if an off-market strategy is right for you?
Let’s connect and discuss your best options in today’s South Bay market.

Work With Dennis

With over three decades of experience as a top ranked agent, he has the answer to any real estate question. He has helped nearly 1000 families buy or sell real estate. His emphasis on customer service has resulted in numerous sales awards and many satisfied clients.